Top 50 All Time All-Teams (2011)
Iowa State University 1,011 (1915–2011) 94 seasons Harold Nichols
Oklahoma State Univ. 1,008 (1914-2011) 92 seasons John Smith *
Oregon State Univ. 961 (1908-2011) 90 seasons Dale Thomas
Springfield College (III) 938 (1914-2011) 92 seasons Doug Parker
Iowa, University of 892 (1910-2011) 100 seasons Dan Gable
Minnesota, University of 878 (1919-2011) 92 seasons Wally Johnson
U.S. Naval Academy 845 (1908-2011) 103 seasons Ed Peery
Lehigh University 839 (1910-2011) 101 seasons Billy Sheridan
Penn State University 829 (1908-2011) 103 seasons Charlie Speidel
Oklahoma, University of 794 (1919-2011) 88 seasons Stan Abel
Michigan, University of 745 (1921-2011) 90 seasons Cliff Keen
Wilkes University (III) 745 (1946-2011) 65 seasons John Reese
Appalachian State Univ. 741 (1932-2011) 73 seasons Paul Mance
Cornell University 723 (1907-2011) 104 seasons Rob Koll *
Kent State University 721 (1927-2011) 81 seasons Joe Begala
Northern Iowa Univ. 706 (1922-2011) 87 seasons Chuck Patten
Olivet College (III) 694 (1964-2011) 47 seasons Jare Klein
Ohio State Univ. 693 (1920-2011) 91 seasons Russ Hellickson
Wisconsin Univ. 689 (1910-2011) 98 seasons Barry Davis
Lock Haven Univ. 688 (1939-2011) 68 seasons Carl Poff
Lycoming College (III) 683 (1956-2011) 55 seasons Budd Whitehill
Indiana University 674 (1909-2011) 100 seasons Duane Goldman
U.S. Military Academy 656 (1921-2011) 90 seasons LeRoy Alitz
Illinois University 654 (1910-2011) 99 seasons Mark Johnson
Princeton University 647 (1904-2011) 107 seasons John Johnston
New Jersey, The College (III) 639 (1966-2011) 45 seasons David Icenhower *ret
North Idaho Jr. Coll. (JuCo) 633 (1969-2011) 42 seasons John Owen
Franklin & Marshall 629 (1933-2011) 85 seasons Charles W. Mayser
Nebraska University 619 (1910-2011) 90 seasons Tim Neumann
Wartburg College (III) 616 (1950-2011) 59 seasons Jim Miller
North Carolina, Univ. of 613 (1922-2011) 89 seasons Bill Lam
North Carolina State 609 (1924-2011) 83 seasons Bob Guzzo
Augsburg College (III) 608 (1948-2011) 63 seasons Jeff Swenson
St. John’s Univ. (III) 587 (1941-2011) 66 seasons John Elton
Minn. State-Mankato (II) 584 (1950-2011) 61 seasons Robert Macias
Nebraska-Omaha (II) 584 (1948-2011)** 57 seasons Mike Denney *
Calif. POLY SLO 577 (1953-2011) 58 seasons Vaughn Hitchcock
Rutgers Univ. 577 (1930-2011) 75 seasons John Sacchi
Delaware Valley College (III) 569 (1962-2011) 49 seasons Robert Floyd Marshall
Michigan State Univ. 568 (1886-2011) 94 seasons Grady Peninger
East Stroudsburg 562 (1930-2011) 77 seasons Clyde Whitman
Pennsylvania, Univ. of 561 (1904-2011) 107 seasons Roger Reina
Cornell College (III) 560 (1922-2011) 87 seasons Steve DeVries
Hofstra Univ. 558 (1947-2011) 64 seasons Bob Gretchell
Bloomsburg Univ. 557 (1936-2011) 59 seasons Roger Sanders
West Virginia Univ. 556 (1920-2011) 86 seasons Craig Turnbull *
Wabash College (III) 552 (1958-2011) 53 seasons Max Servies
Ursinus College (III) 547 (1929-2011) 82 seasons Bill Racich
SUNY-Cortland (III) 544 (1946-2011) 65 seasons Gene Nighman
Ohio Northern (III) 542 (1966-2011) 45 seasons Ron Beaschler
Number of seasons can be less than number of years possible due to schools suspending their teams during war time.
** = UNO has announced it will discontinue it’s wrestling team so it can make the expensive move up to D-I basketball

